Certainty levels

For those events with “speculation” attributes, Certainty levels can be determined according to the Speculation cues/Method cues. However, in some cases, it is difficult to determine the certainty levels, so that those events do not have any certainty levels.

Superposition suggests nucleophilic attack by the 4'-phosphopantetheine on the alpha-phosphate of ATP.
T1 MethodCue 0 13 Superposition
T2 SpeculationCue 14 22 suggests
T3 NucleophilicAttack 23 42 nucleophilic attack
T4 OtherCompound 50 71 4'-phosphopantetheine
T5 FunctionalGroup 78 94 alpha-phosphate
T6 OtherCompound 98 101 ATP
E1 NucleophilicAttack:T3 Agent:T4 Theme:T5 Cue:T2 Cue2:T1
R1 whole_part Arg1:T6 Arg2:T5
A1 Speculation E1
A2 Certainty E1 Probable
Asp40 is positioned appropriately to protonate the purine leaving group.
T1 AminoAcid 0 5 Asp40
T2 SpeculationCue 9 33 positioned appropriately
T3 Protonation 37 46 protonate
T4 OtherCompound 51 57 purine
T5 EntityProperty 58 71 leaving group
E1 Protonation:T3 Agent:T1 Theme:T4 Cue:T2
R1 corresponds_to Arg1:T5 Arg2:T4
A1 Speculation E1
A2 Certainty E1 Confirmed
A3 EntityAttribute T5 ReactivePart
Structural studies show that arcabose is modified upon binding.
T1 MethodCue 0 18 Structural studies
T2 SpeculationCue 19 23 show
T3 OtherCompound 29 37 arcabose
T4 BondFormation 41 49 modified
T5 Interaction 55 62 binding
E1 BondFormation:T4 Theme:T3 Cue:T1 Cue2:T2
E2 Interaction:T5 Theme:T3 Cue:T1 Cue2:T2
A1 Speculation E1
A2 Certainty E1 Confirmed
A3 Speculation E2
A4 Certainty E2 Confirmed
Molecular mechanics calculations show possible binding conformations.
T1 MethodCue 0 32 Molecular mechanics calculations
T2 SpeculationCue 33 37 show
T3 SpeculationCue 38 46 possible
T4 Interaction 47 54 binding
T5 EntityProperty 55 68 conformations
E1 Interaction:T4 Theme:T5 Cue:T1 Cue2:T2 Cue3:T3
A1 Speculation E1
A2 Certainty E1 Probable

The following table indicates Speculation cues/Method cues and corresponding certainty levels (Confirmed, Probable, Unlikely):

Speculation cues/Method cues Certainty Comments
31P NMR analyses Confirmed “Probable” combined with “suggest”
Analysis of this structure Confirmed “Probable” combined with “suggest”
EPR studies Confirmed -
Solvent isotope effect studies Confirmed -
Steady-state kinetic analysis Confirmed -
Structural analyses Confirmed -
Structural analysis Confirmed -
Structural studies Confirmed -
Support for Confirmed -
These findings emphasize Confirmed -
These results clearly indicate Confirmed -
agree well with Confirmed -
Analysis Confirmed -
analysis of crystal and molecular structures Confirmed -
appropriately Confirmed -
can be concluded Confirmed -
clearly Confirmed -
clearly demonstrate importance Confirmed -
conclude Confirmed -
concluded Confirmed -
confirm Confirmed -
confirmed Confirmed -
consistent with Confirmed -
corroborates observation Confirmed -
crystallographic study Confirmed -
define Confirmed -
defined in structure Confirmed -
demonstrably Confirmed -
demonstrate Confirmed -
demonstrated Confirmed -
demonstrates Confirmed -
demonstrating Confirmed -
describe Confirmed -
enable us to identify Confirmed -
ensures Confirmed -
established Confirmed -
establishes presence of Confirmed -
evidence Confirmed -
exhibit Confirmed -
exhibits Confirmed -
first detailed biochemical study that probes Confirmed -
following conclusions Confirmed -
found Confirmed -
further evidenced by observation Confirmed -
generally agreed well with Confirmed -
have previously shown Confirmed -
ideally located for Confirmed -
identification Confirmed -
identified Confirmed -
identify Confirmed -
in agreement with Confirmed -
in agreement with experimental mutagenesis results Confirmed -
in support of Confirmed -
indicate Confirmed -
indicates Confirmed -
indicating Confirmed -
kinetic analyses Confirmed “Probable” combined with “suggest”
kinetic studies Confirmed -
known Confirmed -
leading to conclusion Confirmed -
manifests Confirmed -
measured Confirmed -
model concurs with recent observations Confirmed -
more likely Confirmed -
most consistent with Confirmed -
must Confirmed -
must be Confirmed -
mutational analysis Confirmed -
observed Confirmed -
observing Confirmed -
offers direct evidence Confirmed -
pH-dependent rate analysis Confirmed -
pinpoint Confirmed -
placed perfectly for Confirmed -
poised Confirmed -
positioned Confirmed -
positioned appropriately Confirmed -
positioned approximately for Confirmed -
present study Confirmed -
presenting Confirmed -
previously been shown Confirmed -
previously known Confirmed -
previously reported Confirmed -
proton NMR studies Confirmed -
provided important information Confirmed -
proving Confirmed -
recent identification Confirmed -
reflecting Confirmed -
report Confirmed -
reported Confirmed -
results support Confirmed -
reveal Confirmed -
reveal structural basis Confirmed -
revealing Confirmed -
reveals Confirmed -
should Confirmed -
show Confirmed -
showed Confirmed -
showing evidence Confirmed -
shown Confirmed -
shows Confirmed -
site-directed mutagenesis Confirmed -
solved Confirmed -
steady-state rate analysis Confirmed -
structural basis Confirmed -
structural studies Confirmed -
study Confirmed -
suggested previously Confirmed -
suggests counterintuitive conclusion Confirmed -
suitable for Confirmed -
support Confirmed -
supports Confirmed -
supports suggestion Confirmed -
underscore Confirmed -
underscored importance Confirmed -
unified view Confirmed -
well positioned Confirmed -
widely-studied Confirmed -
Implications Probable -
Insights into Probable -
MD simulation Probable -
Modeling Probable -
Modelling of suggests Probable -
Modelling suggests Probable -
Modelling to superpose Probable -
Models Probable -
Molecular dynamics simulations Probable -
Molecular mechanics calculations show Probable -
Molecular modeling suggests Probable -
These results favor Probable -
This model features Probable -
account at least in part for Probable -
allows Probable -
apparent Probable -
appear to Probable -
appear to involve Probable -
appears Probable -
appears likely Probable -
appears reasonably favourable Probable -
appears to Probable -
appears to be Probable -
appropriate position for Probable -
attractive and precedented Probable -
avoids some serious difficulties Probable -
believe Probable -
can Probable -
can be described Probable -
can be interpreted Probable -
can be rationalized Probable -
can now propose Probable -
can probably be Probable -
cannot Probable -Also negation cue
considered Probable -
consistent with hypothesis Probable -
construction observed structure readily allows Probable -
could Probable -
could be Probable -
deserves further exploration Probable -
equally plausible Probable -
expected Probable -
expected to Probable -
explains Probable -
explains why Probable -
for example Probable -
gain insights into Probable -
gas-phase calculations Probable -
give information on Probable -
highlight importance Probable -
hypothesize Probable -
ideally situated for Probable -
illustrating Probable -
implicated Probable -
implicates Probable -
implication of this work Probable -
implications Probable -
imply Probable -
implying Probable -
inhibitor binding studies Probable -
insights from molecular dynamics simulations Probable -
insights into Probable -
interpreted Probable -
likely Probable -
likely reason Probable -
likely to be Probable -
made considerable strides Probable -
may Probable -
may also suggest Probable -
may be Probable -
may be attributed Probable -
may be important Probable -
may explain Probable -
might Probable -
might anticipate Probable -
mimics Probable -
model Probable -
model building calculations Probable -
modelled Probable -
molecular dynamics simulation Probable -
molecular modeling suggest Probable -
most likely Probable -
most likely combination Probable -
offers possibility Probable -
our understanding Probable -
perhaps Probable -
polarizable continuum model Probable -
possible Probable -
postulated Probable -
potential Probable -
predict Probable -
predicted Probable -
predicted sequence Probable -
predicts Probable -
presumably Probable -
presumed Probable -
previously proposed Probable -
probably Probable -
promising Probable -
proposal explains Probable -
proposals Probable -
propose Probable -
propose model Probable -
proposed Probable -
provide basis for model Probable -
provide details that support and extend Probable -
provide insights into Probable -
provided structural models Probable -
provides Probable -
provides basis for understanding Probable -
provides new insights Probable -
providing rationale Probable -
providing unprecedented insights into Probable -
putative Probable -
quantum-classical molecular dynamics simulations Probable -
rather Probable -
required Probable -
revealed Probable -
seems Probable -
strongly suggested Probable -
studied Probable -
suggest Probable -
suggested Probable -
suggested to resemble Probable -
suggesting Probable -
suggesting possibility Probable -
suggestive of Probable -
suggests Probable -
support model Probable -
support proposals Probable -
tested Probable -
thought Probable -
understand Probable -
would predict Probable -
would provide Probable -
favored over Probable/Unlikely “probable” before cue and “unlikely” after cue
arguing against Unlikely -
less Unlikely -
low residual Unlikely -
lower propensity Unlikely -
seems unlikely Unlikely -
showed much lower Unlikely -